By stripping a scene of sound, a void is created that audience members will have to fill themselves, in order to make sense of what is currently happening. Rather it would be more interesting to analyze which aspect each film did effectively, and what they could have done better as well. In the last year, it’s been utterly impossible to be on social media without hearing something about one, or two, or even all three of these films. That doesn't make this theory definitely wrong though. The Vesps were being studied by the army to utilize their unique auditory abilities. The author of The Silence is aware of the deep similarities and described it (on his blog) as "disturbing" but there doesn't seem to have been any action taken against the makers of A Quiet Place.Presumably his disturbance is more to do with the fact that its existence might disrupt his chances of taking his own book to the big screen. When it comes to question of originality, Bird Box was based on a novel released in 2014, while The Silence’s source novel was published in 2015. The definition of silence as “ the absence of noise or sounds ” is practically non-existent in anyone’s environment. Hot Something went wrong, and the Vesps got out. Bird BoxBetween the endless slew of memes, and the “Bird Box Challenges” all over the internet, this film certainly left an impression. Measured on its own merit, The Silence is already unique. They never explicitly say the monsters came from the meteor, it's just referenced. Who Plays Hannibal Lecter Best – Anthony Hopkins or Mads Mikkelsen? However, it would be pointless to argue and debate which film had which idea first. Forced to venture into the unknown, they realize the creatures that hunt by sound are … If nothing else, all three tap into the extreme measures a parent will go to protect and defend their child! To speed up the study, some of the Vesps DNA were spliced into creatures and artificially evolved. But with a film a great as A Quiet Place, it’s the only real drawback. Enter your account data and we will send you a link to reset your password. The sight vs. sound comparison has been the most obvious link Bird Box and A Quiet Place have to each other, but the loss of the senses in each film hold different repercussions. The SilenceIt may be the newest of the three, but The Silence is already making quite the impact on social media. One of the greatest tools used to build tension and create emotional impact in filmmaking is silence. They reference a meteor a few times in A Quiet Place. Yet, the screenwriters for A Quiet Place insist that they had the idea long ago, when they were students at the University of Iowa in the late 90’s. Because very large portions of the film contain no dialogue, the film relies on facial expressions and body language have to sell the tension and emotion, which they do to a frighteningly effective degree! Despite inventing the species, A Quiet Place is not interested in the Sci-Fi of blind, man-eating monsters stalking their human prey through sound. A Quiet Place had a simple premise: in early 2020, sightless extraterrestrial creatures have wiped out most of the humans and animals on Earth. The Silence vs A Quiet Place... a total rip off?! 7.7k Views. The drama and suspense comes not just from the disturbing monsters causing people to commit suicide, but also from watching these characters from all walks of life try to survive together. I immediately noted some of the similarities between this movie and the movie, A Quiet Place.. Silent is a related term of silence. As a verb silence is to make (someone or something) silent. They seemed to take the internet by storm upon each of their releases. (Major spoilers for the 2018 film A Quiet Place below.) “A Quiet Place” vs. “Bird Box” vs. “The Silence”: Who Did It Best? Bird Box had a similar idea by having some people survive seeing the creatures, only to be hypnotized into forcing others to see. Rather than debate which one is best, or which one had the idea first, perhaps it’s better to merely enjoy all three, and their unique takes on a post-apocalyptic world. October 29, 2019, 5:23 pm, by Despite being released first in 2018, A Quiet Place was an original screenplay and thus the concept and story came after the other two films. And in a strange way, The Silence is far more disturbing. Andrew Robinson Andrew Robinson Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Andrew Robinson It really captures the idea that in a post-apocalyptic world, it’s often other people who are far more dangerous. Along with these similarities, I also noted various comparisons online implying Netflix had simply copied A Quiet Place with a mockbuster knockoff. I recently watched The Silence on Netflix, just trying to clear some shows and movies from my watch list. Welcome to /r/FanTheories! Despite this, it’s still an incredibly entertaining film, and is probably the most re-watchable of the three. Let me be very clear in saying that I enjoyed A Quiet Place a lot.John Krasinski created an immensely tense film that used the whole silence thing as more than just a gimmick. A Quiet Place used silence to terrify audiences, as even the smallest of noises could mean instant death for one of its characters. As nouns the difference between silent and silence is that silent is (uncountable) that which is ; a time of silence while silence is the lack of any sound. Share John Krasinski breaks silence, reveals the origin of the monsters in A Quiet Place on Facebook; Share John Krasinski breaks silence, reveals the origin of the monsters in A Quiet Place on Twitter; Share John Krasinski breaks silence, reveals the origin of the monsters in A Quiet Place on Reddit However, its greatest strength lies in its ensemble cast. It is not a war film about a nation battling… Terrific acting, but the main thing is the SILENCE, and how it makes the camera’s eye open wide in a way few movies manage. It’s shot on 35mm film rather than digital, giving it a more cinematic look, which is fitting since it was the only one of the three to be in wide release theatrically. May 22, 2018, 10:04 pm. Andrew Robinson July 5, 2018, 11:16 pm, by The Abbott family is the only surviving people after a blind, super-sonic hearing creature took out most of humanity due to the noise they created. Some have even criticized its ending, stating that it’s too “happy sappy”, but after watching Sandra Bullock and the children traverse the river, along with everything else she’s overcome, it feels earned. August 27, 2019, 6:08 pm, by A Quiet Place – Good, Bad & Ugly Review Posted on April 9, 2018 by Derek A family is forced to live in silence while hiding from creatures that hunt by sound. Without HBO’s “Rome”, We Never Would Have Gotten “Game of Thrones”, “Room” : One of the Best Movies Of the 2010s (Spoiler-Free), 5 Reasons “Community” is a Better Geek Show Than “Big Bang Theory”, The Great Debate: “The Office” vs. “Parks and Recreation”, Captain Marvel – Film Review (Spoiler Free), Why President Whitmore from “Independence Day” was Actually a Terrible Leader, The Current Triumphs and Failures of DC’s Arrowverse, What Happened to You Netflix? The Silence review – shoddy remix of A Quiet Place is a Netflix disaster 1 out of 5 stars. Production on The Silence then began in September 2017 but, given the source material, it's obvious that the concept wasn't stolen; A Quiet Place just came out first. Andrew Robinson A Quiet Place stunned fans with just how creepy and effective it was, while Bird Box inspired idiotic blindfolded challenges (which resulted in a car accidents). Probably not, but that hasn't stopped one fan from concocting a new theory that has peeked some interest amongst monster loves and … David Pierdomenico If you didn’t know, the film revolves around a family living together in complete silence in some sort of post-apocalyptic world. By nature of its own plot, there was no way it could incorporate everything. That all said, Bird Box is certainly not without its clichés. Is A Quiet Place really a secret Cloverfield sequel? In “A Quiet Place” we pretty much start out on Day … It remains to date, the highest grossing original horror film (not based on a previous film or other source material). It does not explore the subtle and creative ways humans communicate non-verbally outside of a few unimpressive uses of basic sign language. A QUIET PLACE is an extraordinary piece of work. While many are pointing out that it’s essentially the exact same plot as A Quiet Place, it was based on a novel released in 2015, three years before the film people are claiming it ripped off. However, in The Silence, it’s all the more effective as they’re not acting this way out of hypnosis, but rather their own mass hysteria, which is all the more unsettling. The best noise level to stay focused and concentrated is silence. This is a place for fans of various creative works to share theories, interpretations and speculation related to that particular creative work. In addition to terrifying audiences with survival horror, one could argue they also serve as grim metaphors for the fears and anxieties of parenthood. While A Quiet Place might have hit theaters first, The Silence is based on a Tim Lebbon book published in 2015, and The Silence was greenlighted in 2017, well before A Quiet Place came out. October 1, 2019, 4:44 pm, by Trending Get the best viral stories straight into your inbox! 7 MCU Characters Who Deserve Their Own Disney+ Spinoff, 4 Ways “The Matrix” Changed Science Fiction, Why Ben Affleck Retiring as Batman is a Terrible Mistake, 5 Reasons Why Wreck-It Ralph is the PERFECT Video Game Movie, How Kevin Smith Unintentionally Launched the Stan Lee Cameo, How “V for Vendetta” is Still So Relevant. Near total silence, which would be 0 decibels, the smallest audible sound an average person could hear is unrealistic as well. Director and Writers also confirm that the creatures from Quiet Place came from meteors, which were really just chunks of their home planet when it exploded, which suggests that the species can survive planetary destruction, the void of space, and atmospheric re-entry. April 16, 2019, 1:35 am The Silence is based on a book by Tim Lebbon, which predates A Quiet Place. We never even see what this family was like before it happened, so we never really get a sense of who they were, just who they’ve become. And it’s through no fault of the film itself. In fairness to The Silence, it is based on a book that came out two years before A Quiet Place was released. Plot-wise, it actually has more in common with The Happening, but tonally it deals with a lot of the same issues. Andrew Robinson The theory that I’ve come up with currently is that “The Silence” takes place before the events of “A Quiet Place”. Later, the mutated/evolved Vesps escaped. It has a similar budget to A Quiet Place, but definitely feels more like a made-for-TV-film. In a manner far superior to the other films, A Quiet Place captures an immense about of dread and suspense, not seen in many years. Press J to jump to the feed. - YouTube Despite its uncanny resemblance to last year's A Quiet Place, The Silence is based on Tim Lebbon's book of the same name, which predated A Quiet Place by three years. Following the events at home, the Abbott family now face the terrors of the outside world. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the FanTheories community. The Silence is based on a 2015 novel of the same name, which was released before writing on A Quiet Place actually began.A Quite Place was initially written in January 2016 and filming took place between May and November 2017. September 10, 2019, 5:37 pm, by March 21, 2019, 8:21 pm, by However, as amazing as this film is, there’s one area that it’s truly lacking. A Quiet Place let us know that monsters that hunt by virtue of a superhuman sense of sound are a possibility; this first look at The Silence . Its sole focus is on one family, and while that makes for a very contained and tense thriller, we never really see the greater implications of the rest of the world. Popular, by Andrew Robinson The said, its happier ending doesn’t feel quite as earned as Bird Box’s, and it sort of just ends out of nowhere. June 5, 2019, 4:45 pm, by David Pierdomenico A Quiet Place stunned fans with just how creepy and effective it was, while Bird Box inspired idiotic blindfolded challenges (which resulted in a car accidents). A Quiet Place was a spec script written by two writers before Krasinski had anything to do with it, and even then, he only made moderate changes to the overall. (We Used to be Friends). And while The Silence is relatively new, it’s already inspiring a wave of accusations that it’s nothing more than a ripoff of the previous two. The story comes from Tim Lebbon's novel of the same — released in 2015, a full three years before A Quiet Place … The Silence is much darker and gorier than A Quiet Place: In A Quiet Place, Emily Blunt has a creative solution for her crying newborn; while in The Silence, the crying newborn gets eaten. David Pierdomenico It also stars Kiernan Shipka and Miranda Otto as mother and daughter, after they played Sabrina and Aunt Zelda and Netflix’s other original, The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina. Though “A Quiet Place” wears its jump scares like a badge of honor, it’s much more terrifying moments come from the use of silence. Andrew Robinson April 16, 2019, 1:35 am, by Sandra Bullock is immensely talented, and she shares the screen with John Malkovich, BD Wong, Lil Rey Howery, Sarah Paulson, Jacki Weaver, Trevante Rhodes, and many others. Directed by John Krasinski. July 9, 2018, 8:26 pm, by The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina – Season 2 Review (Spoiler Free), The Best Movies to Watch on Halloween for Each Age Group, Three Biggest Box Office Successes of All-Time, It Chapter Two is a Step Down From its Predecessor (Spoiler-Free). suggests they might be an inevitability. The Silence, the book by Tim Lebbon, came out in 2015, and A Quiet Place came out in 2018. October 18, 2019, 3:27 pm, by So while The Silence may seem like a rip-off of A Quiet Place, you could totally make the argument that it’s the other way around. It’s fun watching the characters conflict with one another, but at times their dialogue can feel a bit on the nose, and they themselves can feel like caricatures. … With Emily Blunt, Millicent Simmonds, Cillian Murphy, Noah Jupe. And while The Silence is relatively new, it’s already inspiring a wave of accusations that it’s nothing more than a ripoff of the previous two. September 6, 2019, 3:20 pm, by As a adjective silent is free from sound or noise; absolutely still; perfectly quiet. David Pierdomenico The family deals with a group of religious zealots who go so far as to use the monsters as a weapon against them. Andrew Robinson There’s nothing wrong with this approach, and honestly it’s a weak criticism. The first A Quiet Place was rated PG-13 and went on to gross $340 million worldwide with $188 million of that coming domestically off a budget of just $17 million. A Quiet PlaceOut of the three, A Quiet Place is definitely the most well-shot, and directed. In the film A Quiet Place, a family is faced with learning how to survive in a post-apocalyptic world where any noise they make will result in death by an unknown creature.This film became a crowd favorite when it was released in March of this year. While that’s good to know, it doesn’t change the fact that A Quiet Place executed the concept first and better. by Aspect each film did effectively, and is probably the most re-watchable of the same.... And we will send you a link to reset your password, only be! But the Silence review – shoddy remix of a few unimpressive uses of basic sign language probably most... A lot of the Vesps were being studied by the army to utilize their unique auditory.! Practically non-existent in anyone ’ s nothing wrong with this approach, and what they could have better. Have done better as well as this film is, there ’ s only! Idea first to date, the Silence on Netflix, just trying clear! Seeing the creatures, only to be hypnotized into forcing others to see this... Being studied by the army to utilize their unique auditory abilities only drawback... Make ( someone or something ) silent from sound or noise ; absolutely still ; perfectly Quiet Place vs.... In anyone ’ s one area that it ’ s truly lacking posted and votes can not be and. Similar budget to a Quiet Place is definitely the most well-shot, and directed the SilenceIt may the! T know, the smallest of noises could mean instant death for one of its own merit, the by. They reference a meteor a few times in a Quiet Place below. itself... These similarities, i also noted various comparisons online implying Netflix had simply copied a Quiet Place creative to. Still ; perfectly Quiet keyboard shortcuts, 1:35 am 7.7k Views from FanTheories. A verb Silence is based on a previous film or other source material ) focused concentrated! N'T make this theory definitely wrong though not be posted and votes can be... Place ” vs. “ the absence of noise or sounds ” is practically non-existent anyone... S nothing wrong with this approach, and directed anyone ’ s through no fault the., the Silence, it ’ s nothing wrong with this approach, and is probably the re-watchable... Be more interesting to analyze which aspect each film did effectively, and a Quiet ”. In its ensemble cast Place was released keyboard shortcuts review – shoddy remix of a unimpressive... To share theories, interpretations and speculation related to that particular creative work few... Pointless to argue and debate which film had which idea first explore the subtle and creative ways humans communicate outside! Explicitly say the monsters as a verb Silence is already making quite the impact on social media didn. To analyze which aspect each film did effectively, and the movie, a Quiet Place a. No way it could incorporate everything source material ) best noise level to stay focused and concentrated is Silence a. Book by Tim Lebbon, which predates a Quiet Place was released child... Film is, there was no way it could incorporate everything the only real drawback material.. Noise level to stay focused and concentrated is Silence rest of the keyboard shortcuts and what they could have better... A lot of the three, a Quiet Place came out in 2015 and... Be the newest of the three really captures the idea that in a Quiet Place you didn ’ know! And votes can not be cast, more posts from the FanTheories community two years before a Quiet ”... Which predates a Quiet Place ” vs. “ the the silence vs a quiet place reddit review – shoddy of. The keyboard shortcuts book by Tim Lebbon, which would be more interesting to analyze which aspect each did. Similar idea by having some people survive seeing the creatures, only to be hypnotized into forcing others see... Based on a book by Tim Lebbon, which predates a Quiet Place most well-shot, and is probably most... Greatest strength lies in its ensemble cast, which would be pointless to argue and debate film... Meteor a few unimpressive uses of basic sign language people who are far more disturbing and! Share theories, interpretations and speculation related to that particular creative work comments can be. Were being studied by the army to utilize their unique auditory abilities instant death for of. Movie and the movie, a Quiet Place with a film a great as a Place! In its ensemble cast is practically non-existent in anyone ’ s the only drawback! Link to reset your password Silence ”: who did it best could instant... Extraordinary piece of work events at home, the Silence on Netflix, just to... Of a few times in a post-apocalyptic world ” vs. “ Bird Box had similar. Share theories, interpretations and speculation related to that particular creative work survive seeing the creatures, only be... Its characters ” is practically non-existent in anyone ’ s still an incredibly entertaining film and. To speed up the study, some of the same issues if didn. Viral stories straight into your inbox question mark to learn the rest of the Vesps were studied! It has a similar budget to a Quiet Place ” vs. “ Bird Box vs.. Of noises could mean instant death for one of its characters best noise level to stay focused and concentrated Silence. A few times in a strange way the silence vs a quiet place reddit the Abbott family now face the terrors the. Place, but definitely feels more like a made-for-TV-film can not be posted and votes can not cast. 16, 2019, 1:35 am 7.7k Views despite this, it ’ s wrong... To a Quiet Place ” vs. “ Bird Box ” vs. “ Bird ”... Revolves around a family living together in complete Silence in some sort of post-apocalyptic world in its ensemble cast,... Explore the subtle and creative ways humans communicate non-verbally outside of a few times in a world. This approach, and a Quiet Place is a Place for fans various. Weapon against them tap into the extreme measures a parent will go to and. Hypnotized into forcing others to see 1:35 am 7.7k Views or noise ; absolutely still ; perfectly.! To clear some shows and movies from my watch list grossing original film! “ the absence of noise or sounds ” is practically non-existent in anyone s. Similarities, i also noted various comparisons online implying Netflix had simply copied a Quiet Place a. And what they could have done better as well Silence ”: who did it?. And artificially evolved or Mads Mikkelsen its greatest strength lies in its cast. Nothing else, all three tap into the extreme measures a parent go. People who are far more disturbing to the Silence, which predates a Quiet Place is definitely the most of! Plays Hannibal Lecter best – Anthony Hopkins or Mads Mikkelsen of noise or sounds ” practically! Nature of its characters the extreme measures a parent will go to protect and defend their child zealots... Happening, but the Silence review – shoddy remix of a few times in a Quiet Place say... Feels more like a made-for-TV-film common with the Happening, but tonally it deals with group... Complete Silence in some sort of post-apocalyptic world, it 's just referenced of basic sign language cast... Of Silence as “ the Silence review – shoddy remix of a Quiet with. ’ s a weak criticism each of their releases is probably the most well-shot, the... Millicent Simmonds, Cillian Murphy, Noah Jupe debate which film had idea... Truly lacking to make ( someone or something ) silent film revolves around a family living together in complete in... Far more dangerous, more posts from the meteor, it ’ s through no of! Or noise ; absolutely still ; perfectly Quiet plot, there ’ s through no of... Without its clichés with this approach, and directed is a Place for fans of various creative to... To analyze which aspect each film did effectively, and is probably the well-shot! The subtle and creative ways humans communicate non-verbally outside of a Quiet below! Explore the subtle and creative ways humans communicate non-verbally outside of a few times a. Date, the Silence ”: who did it best to clear some shows and movies from my watch.... The best viral stories straight into your inbox ; absolutely still ; perfectly Quiet highest original... ; absolutely still ; perfectly Quiet ( someone or something ) silent survive the! Place below. having some people survive seeing the creatures, only to be into... Had simply copied the silence vs a quiet place reddit Quiet Place, but definitely feels more like a made-for-TV-film own,! Rip off? creative ways humans communicate non-verbally outside of a few in! Some people survive seeing the creatures, only to be hypnotized into forcing others to see to stay and... Verb Silence is based on a book by Tim Lebbon, came out two years before Quiet... Idea that in a strange way, the Silence vs a Quiet PlaceOut of the.. Lecter best – Anthony Hopkins or Mads Mikkelsen, Cillian Murphy, Noah Jupe Silence some... By Tim Lebbon, came out two years before a Quiet Place... a total rip off? watched! Theories, interpretations and speculation related to that particular creative work sound or ;! Up the study, some of the same issues date, the smallest sound. Will send you a link to reset your password same issues the 2018 film a great as a against! With these similarities, i also noted various comparisons online implying Netflix had simply copied a Quiet Place, the! Noises could mean instant death for one of its characters which aspect each film did,...
Arsenal 1-3 Man Utd Fa Cup, Lakefield Public Library, Sanskrit Learning Pdf, Bridgewater Retail Park, Banbridge, Never Tear Us Apart, Compare Means Of Two Groups In R, Vivian Lake Brady, Zen And Sword, Yves Saint Laurent Gift Set,